Showing posts with label critiques. Show all posts
Showing posts with label critiques. Show all posts
First Impact: HARD TRUTHS by Anonymous
It's time for another First Impact Critique,
where we take a look at your queries, first pages, back cover copy, and
more. You want to make an impact right from the start. We're here to
help you do that.
If you'd like to submit your first impact material, send it to firstimpactAE@gmail.com. Details here.
This week we have a query for an upper middle-grade fantasy called HARD TRUTHS. My overall thoughts are at the end. As always, this is just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
Query
Fourteen year old Reyna longs for more in her life. High tea behind higher castle walls isn’t enough. But she gets more than she bargained for at an annual festival where she becomes bonded, by blood and magic, to a peacekeeping dragon.
Fiercely proud, Reyna is determined to become a great Dragoneer, even though she lacks any useful skills. Seriously - any useful skills. Etiquette and embroidery don’t exactly prepare you for endurance and espionage.
Her father, however, has different plans. His nefarious scheme will lead to the death of the peacekeeping dragons that stand in the way of a war to expand his kingdom. He will let nothing, not even the safety of his own daughter, stand in his way.
Confronted with the truth Reyna must choose to either be a good daughter or be a good person. Maybe if she were any good at being a Dragoneer maybe the choice wouldn’t be so hard.
DRAGONEER: HARD TRUTHS is a 50,000-word upper middle-grade fantasy.
I am a member of SCBWI and have written commercial scripts. HARD TRUTHS is my first novel.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Adam's Thoughts
If Reyna ends up being the queen, her name might be too on the nose ;-)
Overall, this is pretty good. It's clear and easy to read, with just a hint of voice.
I would like a little more voice, if possible, but it's not critical. Part of me also wants to know more about Dragoneers and their peacekeeping dragons, but that might clutter the query.
What I'd really like is to better understand Reyna's father's plan and (therefore) the choice she has to make. What makes her father's scheme nefarious? (The query says, but it's not as clear as it could be). What does it mean for Reyna to be a good daughter? Does she kill her own dragon? What does it mean for her to be a good person?
I think it's close, because I get the feeling from the query that you have answers to these questions; they're just not coming across yet. I'd request pages, but I think this query could be even stronger.
What do the rest of you guys think?
If you'd like to submit your first impact material, send it to firstimpactAE@gmail.com. Details here.
This week we have a query for an upper middle-grade fantasy called HARD TRUTHS. My overall thoughts are at the end. As always, this is just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
Query
 |
| Not sure what a "peacekeeping" dragon is, but otherwise okay. |
|
| Last paragraph makes it sounds like she doesn't want to have a dragon. Now she's determined to be the best Dragoneer. |
|
| I'm a bit confused here. Don't know what his scheme is or why the dragons are in the way. |
|
| Not sure about "be a good person," but I'm glad to see a choice :-) |
|
| Hyphenate "50,000-word". |
I am a member of SCBWI and have written commercial scripts. HARD TRUTHS is my first novel.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Adam's Thoughts
If Reyna ends up being the queen, her name might be too on the nose ;-)
Overall, this is pretty good. It's clear and easy to read, with just a hint of voice.
I would like a little more voice, if possible, but it's not critical. Part of me also wants to know more about Dragoneers and their peacekeeping dragons, but that might clutter the query.
What I'd really like is to better understand Reyna's father's plan and (therefore) the choice she has to make. What makes her father's scheme nefarious? (The query says, but it's not as clear as it could be). What does it mean for Reyna to be a good daughter? Does she kill her own dragon? What does it mean for her to be a good person?
I think it's close, because I get the feeling from the query that you have answers to these questions; they're just not coming across yet. I'd request pages, but I think this query could be even stronger.
What do the rest of you guys think?
First Impact: THE FIRE LOTUS (First Page) by Renee Ahdieh
It's time for another First Impact Critique, where we take a look at your queries, first pages, back cover copy, and more. You want to make an impact right from the start. We're here to help you do that.
If you'd like to submit your first impact material, send it to firstimpactAE@gmail.com. Details here.
This week we have the first page for THE FIRE LOTUS, the YA urban fantasy from Renee Ahdieh, whose query we critiqued last week. My overall thoughts are at the end. As always, this is all just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
First Page
The storm was closing in on the family of five.
In the distance, a grumble of thunder gave a final warning.
“Hurry! Wrap everything up!” the mother urged.
Two teenaged girls packed away the remnants of a picnic. Their father discarded the trash while their mother shook a blanket in the air to dislodge the lingering crumbs from its surface.
“Please, don’t throw away the silverware, Jia!”
“I won’t, Mom!” Jia yelled. Under her breath, she added, “Chill out,”she continued under her breath.
“Where’s your brother?”
Jia shrugged and started lugging a cooler towards the parking lot. Droplets of rain began to splash on the hot asphalt. Wisps of coiling steam rose in their wake.
The echoing tolls rolled closer as grey clouds swirled above and the horizon hissed with a charge of menace. Wet moss and bitter earth perfumed the air, leaving behind a metallic tang as an afterthought.
“Quick! Use ‘ominous’ in a sentence!” Jia joked to her sister Minar.
“Such a Nerd Queen. Help me with this friggin’ basket or I will go ominous on you.”
“Yeah, not quite, Mini. It just lacks that sense of impending doom,” Jia said with a chuckle. “By the way, have you seen Daniel?”
“I saw him a few minutes ago; behind that big tree over there. He was still practicing with his bow and arrows.”
Jia sighed and held up her right fist. Minar mirrored the gesture without a word.
One, two, three . . . shoot.
Minar’s rock smashed with triumph into Jia’s scissors.
“Yeah, buddy. I guess fortune does favor the—what was it? The bold?” Minar teased.
“In this case, I think you mean ‘the wicked.’ As in, downright twisted.” Jia’s green eyes sparkled with mirth.
“You wish.”
Mindful of their mother’s ever-watchful gaze, Jia quickly gave her twin the finger before traipsing the distance to the large oak tree.
Adam's Thoughts
For me, the main problem I have here is I don't feel connected to Jia at all. I think you did a great job making the scene feel ominous (and I think I like that you even lampshade it in the dialog (warning: TV Tropes link)), and I thought the dialog between Jia and Minar was fun. But I didn't understand why Jia was so flippant about a threatening situation.
For me, part of the problem is understanding what point of view we're in. I'm used to YA being 3rd person limited, meaning we get focused attention on one character's thoughts and feelings. That doesn't mean you have to do it that way, of course, but for me, it's a little jarring that the narrator clearly feels the scene is ominous, but Jia doesn't. I kind of expect one or the other to mention that fact.
For example, if this were 3rd person limited, then we'd see the storm from Jia's point of view. Stuff along the lines of, "In the distance, a grumble of thunder gave a final warning. Jia snorted in reply."
If it were 3rd person omniscient, however, I'd expect the narrator to point out the fact that Jia either didn't know or didn't care about the threat. Something like, "Jia shrugged and started lugging a cooler towards the parking lot, oblivious to the looming storm."
So that's my advice: be aware of what POV you're using and who your narrator is (whether omniscient or in Jia's head). There's a lot of fun writing here, but foundational things like that can lost your reader's trust.
What do the rest of you guys think?
If you'd like to submit your first impact material, send it to firstimpactAE@gmail.com. Details here.
This week we have the first page for THE FIRE LOTUS, the YA urban fantasy from Renee Ahdieh, whose query we critiqued last week. My overall thoughts are at the end. As always, this is all just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
First Page
The storm was closing in on the family of five.
|
| Not sure why this paragraph is separated from the previous one. |
“Hurry! Wrap everything up!” the mother urged.
|
| I'm used to YA being 3rd-person limited, so this detached viewpoint threw me. |
“Please, don’t throw away the silverware, Jia!”
“I won’t, Mom!” Jia yelled. Under her breath, she added, “Chill out,”
“Where’s your brother?”
Jia shrugged and started lugging a cooler towards the parking lot. Droplets of rain began to splash on the hot asphalt. Wisps of coiling steam rose in their wake.
|
| Tolls? The thunder? |
“Quick! Use ‘ominous’ in a sentence!” Jia joked to her sister Minar.
“Such a Nerd Queen. Help me with this friggin’ basket or I will go ominous on you.”
“Yeah, not quite, Mini. It just lacks that sense of impending doom,” Jia said with a chuckle. “By the way, have you seen Daniel?”
“I saw him a few minutes ago; behind that big tree over there. He was still practicing with his bow and arrows.”
Jia sighed and held up her right fist. Minar mirrored the gesture without a word.
One, two, three . . . shoot.
Minar’s rock smashed with triumph into Jia’s scissors.
“Yeah, buddy. I guess fortune does favor the—what was it? The bold?” Minar teased.
|
| Mirth, even though she lost? |
“You wish.”
Mindful of their mother’s ever-watchful gaze, Jia quickly gave her twin the finger before traipsing the distance to the large oak tree.
Adam's Thoughts
For me, the main problem I have here is I don't feel connected to Jia at all. I think you did a great job making the scene feel ominous (and I think I like that you even lampshade it in the dialog (warning: TV Tropes link)), and I thought the dialog between Jia and Minar was fun. But I didn't understand why Jia was so flippant about a threatening situation.
For me, part of the problem is understanding what point of view we're in. I'm used to YA being 3rd person limited, meaning we get focused attention on one character's thoughts and feelings. That doesn't mean you have to do it that way, of course, but for me, it's a little jarring that the narrator clearly feels the scene is ominous, but Jia doesn't. I kind of expect one or the other to mention that fact.
For example, if this were 3rd person limited, then we'd see the storm from Jia's point of view. Stuff along the lines of, "In the distance, a grumble of thunder gave a final warning. Jia snorted in reply."
If it were 3rd person omniscient, however, I'd expect the narrator to point out the fact that Jia either didn't know or didn't care about the threat. Something like, "Jia shrugged and started lugging a cooler towards the parking lot, oblivious to the looming storm."
So that's my advice: be aware of what POV you're using and who your narrator is (whether omniscient or in Jia's head). There's a lot of fun writing here, but foundational things like that can lost your reader's trust.
What do the rest of you guys think?
First Impact: THE FIRE LOTUS by Renee Ahdieh
It's time for another First Impact Critique, where we take a look at your queries, first pages, back cover copy, and more. You want to make an impact right from the start. We're here to help you do that.
If you'd like to submit your first impact material, send it to firstimpactAE@gmail.com. Details here.
This week we have the query for THE FIRE LOTUS, a YA urban fantasy from Renee Ahdieh. My overall thoughts are at the end. As always, this is all just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
Query
If you'd like to submit your first impact material, send it to firstimpactAE@gmail.com. Details here.
This week we have the query for THE FIRE LOTUS, a YA urban fantasy from Renee Ahdieh. My overall thoughts are at the end. As always, this is all just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
Query
|
| Nice hook. |
Jia Ryan was supposed to start college in three weeks, not get struck by a bolt of lightning and die in front of her family.
|
| I like the voice, but there's a lot of stuff going on here all of a sudden. Simplified sentence structures might help. |
What’s more, she’s pretty sure she wasn’t meant to wake up in a lab days later with a scientist hovering over her, welcoming her into the world of the living dead. Yeah, and that’s not even calling to question the irritatingly serene genie nearby. Or his strange request that she take up arms in their ongoing struggle against reanimated corpses held under the sway of a powerful sorcerer. Right. Not so much, Master Yoda.
After all, this isn’t her fight. She’s only eighteen, for crying out loud.
|
| I feel like the questions are getting to be a little much. Just my opinion. |
Wait. She gets to train in a slew of martial arts? Learn how to wield a katana? And, hold the phone, somebody probably should have mentioned that the young samurai teaching her is darkly enigmatic and sexier than sin.
Okay. This might not totally suck.
As she settles into her new role as an undead warrior, Jia soon learns that the aforementioned baddie sorcerer intends to unleash the full brunt of his mind-controlling blood sorcery onto mankind. Once she begins to grasp that the idyllic world she existed in for eighteen years is being threatened, there’s no going back.
This is now her fight.
THE FIRE LOTUS is an 80,000-word work of YA urban fantasy with series potential.
Adam's Thoughts
This is pretty good. I love the voice, and there's a clear conflict here. There's no sadistic choice like I keep harping on, but I think the mentions of samurai and undead warriors sufficiently distracted me from that fact ;-)
One thing to be careful of is to make sure the voice doesn't get in the way. It's a great voice, like I said, but there were a couple of times I felt it was a bit too much. Now that's totally just my opinion; others might feel differently. And really, it's just a nitpick.
And if you did have a sadistic choice to build up to at the end, I think this might be perfect.
But that's just me. What do the rest of you guys think?
First Impact: THE EYELET DOVE by Lindsay Kitson (First Page)
It's time for another First Impact Critique,
where we take a look at your queries, first pages, back cover copy, and more.
You want to make an impact right from the start. We're here to help
you do that.
If you'd like to submit your first impact material, send it to firstimpactAE@gmail.com. Details here.
Remember, anyone who offers their comments this month is eligible for either $10 for Amazon or B&N OR a 20-page critique from me.
This week we have the first page for THE EYELET DOVE, a dieselpunk novel (yes, that's a thing) from Lindsay Kitson. You might remember we did the back cover copy of this book last year.
My overall thoughts are at the end. As always, this is all just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
First Page
Claire wanted to fly.
It was an overcast day but the clouds were high up when she walked out onto the River City Base tarmac for pilot tryouts. Claire had tucked her shoulder-length hair up under her flight cap and drawn her goggles down over her face. With any luck, no one would guess her sex until after she’d proved herself in the sky.
She’d never felt so lucky to have a less than feminine jawline and small breasts.
That was why she’d joined the Ladies Division of the Avaline Air Guard in the first place, whatever she told
people. She didn’t tell people the truth because she knew they would only laugh at her.
The truth was, working alongside the men who flew the machines that sailed among the clouds was the closest she might ever come to flying them herself.
But even that wasn’t enough for her any more.
The concrete airstrip stretched out to her left, bright white in the diffused sunlight. Some of the dreadnought crew had come out to watch the tryouts. Some of the hangar deck crew were out of their canvas coveralls, but the fly-boys wore their leather flight jackets like badges of pride.
Thomas wasn’t there though, thank Pete. Her boyfriend would have recognized her for sure, and he wouldn’t have hesitated to out her. It had taken no end of cajoling to convince him to teach her. He was a
creep—enough that the other girls wanted nothing to do with him. He made her skin crawl every time he laid his hands on her, and he bragged to the other pilots that she liked to do it in the sky, with no end of uncreative puns applied to the word cockpit.
Adam's Thoughts
I like the setting, but if you recall my comments from your back cover copy, you knew that.
I think I get the Ladies' Division thing, but it took me a couple of reads. I guess the Ladies' Division isn't allowed to actually fly, yes? That could be clarified.
I don't have a lot to add beyond my comments in the text. It does immediately bring LEVIATHAN to mind, perhaps too much for someone who has read that. So I personally want to know what makes this novel different as soon as possible. And the last paragraph creeps me out, so to keep Claire sympathetic, I want to know why he's still "her boyfriend," rather than her ex or something.
Other than that, I'm anxious to get to the action :-) What do the rest of you guys think?
If you'd like to submit your first impact material, send it to firstimpactAE@gmail.com. Details here.
Remember, anyone who offers their comments this month is eligible for either $10 for Amazon or B&N OR a 20-page critique from me.
This week we have the first page for THE EYELET DOVE, a dieselpunk novel (yes, that's a thing) from Lindsay Kitson. You might remember we did the back cover copy of this book last year.
My overall thoughts are at the end. As always, this is all just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
First Page
Claire wanted to fly.
|
| The last sentence here makes me immediately think of LEVIATHAN. I'm hoping this differentiates itself from that soon. |
She’d never felt so lucky to have a less than feminine jawline and small breasts.
That was why she’d joined the Ladies Division of the Avaline Air Guard in the first place, whatever she told
|
| I'm confused. If there's a Ladies' Air Guard, why does she have to hide? |
The truth was, working alongside the men who flew the machines that sailed among the clouds was the closest she might ever come to flying them herself.
But even that wasn’t enough for her any more.
The concrete airstrip stretched out to her left, bright white in the diffused sunlight. Some of the dreadnought crew had come out to watch the tryouts. Some of the hangar deck crew were out of their canvas coveralls, but the fly-boys wore their leather flight jackets like badges of pride.
|
| Creepy. I hope the very next sentence explains why she's still with him. I guess because he teaches her? |
creep—enough that the other girls wanted nothing to do with him. He made her skin crawl every time he laid his hands on her, and he bragged to the other pilots that she liked to do it in the sky, with no end of uncreative puns applied to the word cockpit.
Adam's Thoughts
I like the setting, but if you recall my comments from your back cover copy, you knew that.
I think I get the Ladies' Division thing, but it took me a couple of reads. I guess the Ladies' Division isn't allowed to actually fly, yes? That could be clarified.
I don't have a lot to add beyond my comments in the text. It does immediately bring LEVIATHAN to mind, perhaps too much for someone who has read that. So I personally want to know what makes this novel different as soon as possible. And the last paragraph creeps me out, so to keep Claire sympathetic, I want to know why he's still "her boyfriend," rather than her ex or something.
Other than that, I'm anxious to get to the action :-) What do the rest of you guys think?
First Impact: INGENICIDE by Joan He (First Page)
It's time for another First Impact Critique,
where we take a look at your queries, first pages, back cover copy, and more.
You want to make an impact right from the start. We're here to help
you do that.
If you'd like to submit your first impact material, send it to firstimpactAE@gmail.com. Details here.
Remember, anyone who offers their comments this month is eligible for either $10 for Amazon or B&N OR a 20-page critique from me.
This week we have the first page for INGENICIDE, a YA dystopian from Joan He, whose query we read last week. My overall thoughts are at the end. As always, this is all just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
First Page
It’s the first dance I’ve gone to in years.
Mom tells me to stay away from the spirits. She glances out the car window, at the Technicolor lights that dart across Kennie’s packed driveway. Her brows knit together—I know what she’s thinking. Music thrums in the asphalt, vibrating through the soles of my shoes as I swing my feet onto the ground.
Dad rolls down the window. “Enjoy yourself. Today’s your day.”
“We’re so proud of you,” Mom adds, the little knot of worry vanishing. I blow them both a kiss. Dad honks. They drive away.
I knock and wait, apprehensive. It won’t just be our School at the post-graduation party tonight. Fairfax, Georgetown, and DC should be here, too. Already, I catch drifts of new voices among the blasting speakers and the familiar lull of the old. I relax when it’s Tess who opens the door.
“Hey, Sibyl,” she yells over the song. Her eyes are heavily made-up, but nothing competes with her dress. It’s got a million iridescent scales that scatter in ombre from the hemline. Rainbow lights dart around her form. They make Tess sparkle.
“You’ve outdone yourself,” I yell back. She laughs.
“Did you expect anything less?”
No, I didn’t. Not from Style Enhancer Tess Wittle of Alexandria, which is one School of five in the DC and Virginia sector. All the Schools belong to the Training Of Prodigies system, better known by its acronym: TOP.
Tess doesn’t wait for an answer. The door closes behind us as she pulls me into the mass of dancing graduates. She’s whisked away after barely a minute, but I don’t mind. TOP Peers who recognize me pull me into their circles. They ask me about my plans after the one-month hiatus and congratulate me when I tell them that I’ll be apprenticing under a team of Experts in the renovation of the White House. Between beats, I ask them the same question. One Flesh Weaver leaves late June for a Bioprinting conference in Japan. Russell, Alexandria’s resident Beauty Translator, will be hosting his first art show in New York. Slaps and fist pumps go around, and then again, until it gets a bit overwhelming.
Adam's Thoughts
I really want to know what she thinks her mother is thinking :-) It seems like she's apprehensive, but I'm not clear about what, exactly. What is she afraid will happen? That knowledge alone might carry me through this piece a lot more strongly.
There are some world bits here that are intriguing -- the Flesh Weaver, for instance. But I'm not picking up enough to keep me hooked. That doesn't mean you have to add more just yet, but it's something to think about.
I kept getting hung up on simple words that were capitalized, but I didn't know why -- like School and Expert. I'm sure there's a reason, but because I don't know what it is, I find myself wondering why it doesn't just say school and expert. Why are they special enough to mark them as proper nouns? The problem is they appear to mean exactly the same thing as the common terms. It's similar to the problem of foreign terms: if a "hobarjee" is actually a duck, then it's better to just say duck.
These are nitpicks, and that's a good thing. I can't say I'm hooked yet, but I'm not turned off either. I think it just needs some turns in the right direction.
So what do the rest of you guys think?
If you'd like to submit your first impact material, send it to firstimpactAE@gmail.com. Details here.
Remember, anyone who offers their comments this month is eligible for either $10 for Amazon or B&N OR a 20-page critique from me.
This week we have the first page for INGENICIDE, a YA dystopian from Joan He, whose query we read last week. My overall thoughts are at the end. As always, this is all just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
First Page
It’s the first dance I’ve gone to in years.
|
| I'm totally sticking on this: should technicolor be capitalized? I want to know what she thinks her mother's thinking. |
Dad rolls down the window. “Enjoy yourself. Today’s your day.”
“We’re so proud of you,” Mom adds, the little knot of worry vanishing. I blow them both a kiss. Dad honks. They drive away.
I knock and wait, apprehensive. It won’t just be our School at the post-graduation party tonight. Fairfax, Georgetown, and DC should be here, too. Already, I catch drifts of new voices among the blasting speakers and the familiar lull of the old. I relax when it’s Tess who opens the door.
|
| Ombre's a pretty modern term (I had to look it up). Is this near future? |
“You’ve outdone yourself,” I yell back. She laughs.
“Did you expect anything less?”
|
| Not sure why school is capitalized. Kind of a non-sequitur from Tess to the school system. |
Tess doesn’t wait for an answer. The door closes behind us as she pulls me into the mass of dancing graduates. She’s whisked away after barely a minute, but I don’t mind. TOP Peers who recognize me pull me into their circles. They ask me about my plans after the one-month hiatus and congratulate me when I tell them that I’ll be apprenticing under a team of Experts in the renovation of the White House. Between beats, I ask them the same question. One Flesh Weaver leaves late June for a Bioprinting conference in Japan. Russell, Alexandria’s resident Beauty Translator, will be hosting his first art show in New York. Slaps and fist pumps go around, and then again, until it gets a bit overwhelming.
Adam's Thoughts
I really want to know what she thinks her mother is thinking :-) It seems like she's apprehensive, but I'm not clear about what, exactly. What is she afraid will happen? That knowledge alone might carry me through this piece a lot more strongly.
There are some world bits here that are intriguing -- the Flesh Weaver, for instance. But I'm not picking up enough to keep me hooked. That doesn't mean you have to add more just yet, but it's something to think about.
I kept getting hung up on simple words that were capitalized, but I didn't know why -- like School and Expert. I'm sure there's a reason, but because I don't know what it is, I find myself wondering why it doesn't just say school and expert. Why are they special enough to mark them as proper nouns? The problem is they appear to mean exactly the same thing as the common terms. It's similar to the problem of foreign terms: if a "hobarjee" is actually a duck, then it's better to just say duck.
These are nitpicks, and that's a good thing. I can't say I'm hooked yet, but I'm not turned off either. I think it just needs some turns in the right direction.
So what do the rest of you guys think?
First Impact: INGENICIDE by Joan He (Query)
Despite all the noise ($2M in two days, guys! Keep it going!), it's time for another First Impact Critique,
where we take a look at your queries, first pages, back cover copy, and more.
You want to make an impact right from the start. We're here to help
you do that.
If you'd like to submit your first impact material, send it to firstimpactAE@gmail.com. Details here.
The random numbers have favored critiquer Melodie Wright for February's prize. Congratulations, Melodie! And the rest of you remember: anyone who offers their comments this month is eligible for either $10 for Amazon or B&N OR a 20-page critique from me.
This week we have the query for a YA dystopian from Joan He. My overall thoughts are at the end. As always, this is all just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
Query Letter
For sixteen-year-old Sibyl Kenschild, the sky is her limit when it comes to interior design--that is, until the Genocide reaches Alexandria, Virginia, and gatecrashes the graduation party.
In a matter of hours, Sibyl’s world is shattered. Chaos erupts, Peers are slaughtered, and Sibyl has no idea why the Normals have resorted to mass killings of the Ingenium. All she knows is that she’s too young to die. She must survive and protect what remains most important to her--her heart, her spirit, and her sanity.
So when the leaders of the Genocide present a selection of Ingenia with a second shot at living, Sibyl decides play their game. Four Peers will have to summon all that they have learned to create unparalleled rooms for the enemy headquarters. It is a competition that puts at stake the dearest price; with each assignment, one Ingenium is exterminated. As she grows closer to her competitors—in particular, a troubled but gentle boy who designs chillingly twisted rooms—Sibyl is not sure if she has what it takes to win. And if she does, she just might not have enough strength to ignore the fates of the others.
INGENICIDE is a YA dystopian/adventure novel complete at 58,000 words.
Thank you for your time and consideration!
Adam's Thoughts
First of all, I love dystopian novels, and this sounds like it has some cool stuff in it.
Unfortunately, I'm having a hard time figuring out what that cool stuff is. Who are the Peers? Who are the Ingenium? Which one is Sibyl? And why are they designing rooms? That part, in particular, sounds potentially cool, but I can't tell because I don't understand it.
Now understand, the way to fix this is not necessarily to add the information into the existing query. Very often that leads to a bloated query that just raises new questions. Look for things you can cut so that you don't even raise the questions to begin with. For example, do we really need to know about Peers and Ingenium? Maybe you can just say "Sibyl's people," and use the space you save to explain the rooms. Which way you go is up to you and what you want to convey in the query. Just remember, it's okay to skip stuff; the goal is to make the agent want to read more.
What do the rest of you guys think?
If you'd like to submit your first impact material, send it to firstimpactAE@gmail.com. Details here.
The random numbers have favored critiquer Melodie Wright for February's prize. Congratulations, Melodie! And the rest of you remember: anyone who offers their comments this month is eligible for either $10 for Amazon or B&N OR a 20-page critique from me.
This week we have the query for a YA dystopian from Joan He. My overall thoughts are at the end. As always, this is all just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
Query Letter
|
| I think the phrase is "the sky is the limit," but also it's a bit cliche. You can do better. |
|
| Why is Peers capitalized? What's Ingenium? At the moment, I think her life is more important than these things :-) |
|
| My confusion in the 2nd paragraph is making this one impossible to understand. |
INGENICIDE is a YA dystopian/adventure novel complete at 58,000 words.
Thank you for your time and consideration!
Adam's Thoughts
First of all, I love dystopian novels, and this sounds like it has some cool stuff in it.
Unfortunately, I'm having a hard time figuring out what that cool stuff is. Who are the Peers? Who are the Ingenium? Which one is Sibyl? And why are they designing rooms? That part, in particular, sounds potentially cool, but I can't tell because I don't understand it.
Now understand, the way to fix this is not necessarily to add the information into the existing query. Very often that leads to a bloated query that just raises new questions. Look for things you can cut so that you don't even raise the questions to begin with. For example, do we really need to know about Peers and Ingenium? Maybe you can just say "Sibyl's people," and use the space you save to explain the rooms. Which way you go is up to you and what you want to convey in the query. Just remember, it's okay to skip stuff; the goal is to make the agent want to read more.
What do the rest of you guys think?
First Impact: SHADOWCATCHERS by Kimberly Callard
It's time for another First Impact Critique,
where we take a look at your queries, first pages, back cover copy, and more.
You want to make an impact right from the start. We're here to help
you do that.
If you'd like to submit your first impact material, send it to firstimpactAE@gmail.com. Details here.
Remember, anyone who offers their comments this month is eligible for either $10 for Amazon or B&N OR a 20-page critique from me.
This week we have the query for an upper-MG fantasy from Kimberly Callard. My overall thoughts are at the end. As always, this is all just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
Query Letter
Adam's Thoughts
There is a LOT of good here. Stakes and voice in the intro. Inciting incident in the 2nd paragraph. Sadistic choice in the 3rd. It's almost as if you've been reading my comments to the others, Kimberly.
The only comment I have is a nitpick about the choice. It's sadistic all right, but I kind of know what he's going to pick, and I'm curious about where the story goes after that. He doesn't hide in the slums, so what does he do? What's his new goal?
All that to say I feel like there's more story here. Honestly, this is probably good enough to garner requests, but if you wanted to improve it, that's the direction I'd go (but not too far in that direction, lest the query get too long, aye?).
What do the rest of you think?
If you'd like to submit your first impact material, send it to firstimpactAE@gmail.com. Details here.
Remember, anyone who offers their comments this month is eligible for either $10 for Amazon or B&N OR a 20-page critique from me.
This week we have the query for an upper-MG fantasy from Kimberly Callard. My overall thoughts are at the end. As always, this is all just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
Query Letter
At only 14 years old Zane Blackthorne
is the youngest Shadowcatcher on the force. He's also the best. He
has to be. The ridiculous amount of gold he earns hunting down tax
evaders is the only thing keeping him from ending up back in the
slums where he was raised. And he'd rather eat a Narcow than end up
back there.
Zane thinks he's hit the jackpot when
the Empress commissions him to collect the shadow of a political
opponent. Sure, she threatens to sic bounty hunters on him if he
fails, but that doesn't scare Zane. He's too good to fail. At
least, he is until a rat-faced urchin named Meescha gets in his way.
|
| =D |
A victim of the Shadowcatchers herself,
Meescha shows Zane what happens to those who can't afford to buy
their shadows back. Most become husks of their former selves,
withering away with agonizing slowness; the rest die instantly, their
lives snuffed out like street lamps at dawn. Haunted by the faces of
the suffering shadowless, Zane must make a choice: continue living in
luxury as the Empress's enforcer or quit do the right thing and spend what's left of his
life hiding in the slums with a target on his back.
|
| I believe agents assume it's a multiple submission. |
SHADOWCATCHERS is a 48,000-word Upper
MG fantasy told from two viewpoints: Zane's and Meescha's. I am
submitting it to you because (insert personalization here). Please
note it is a multiple submission.
I am an associate member of SCBWI.
Thank you for your time and
consideration.
Adam's Thoughts
There is a LOT of good here. Stakes and voice in the intro. Inciting incident in the 2nd paragraph. Sadistic choice in the 3rd. It's almost as if you've been reading my comments to the others, Kimberly.
The only comment I have is a nitpick about the choice. It's sadistic all right, but I kind of know what he's going to pick, and I'm curious about where the story goes after that. He doesn't hide in the slums, so what does he do? What's his new goal?
All that to say I feel like there's more story here. Honestly, this is probably good enough to garner requests, but if you wanted to improve it, that's the direction I'd go (but not too far in that direction, lest the query get too long, aye?).
What do the rest of you think?
First Impact: WANDERERS by KayC
It's time for another First Impact Critique,
where we take a look at your queries, first pages, back cover copy, and more.
You want to make an impact right from the start. We're here to help
you do that.
If you'd like to submit your first impact material, send it to firstimpactAE@gmail.com. Details here.
Remember, anyone who offers their comments this month is eligible for either $10 for Amazon or B&N OR a 20-page critique from me.
This week we have the first page of a YA fantasy from KayC. My overall thoughts are at the end. As always, this is all just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
First Page
Adam's Thoughts
Writing? Solid. Voice? Great. I've got nothing to say about these things.
My problem here is I don't know what's going on. Normally that wouldn't be so bad, but the problem is that the narrator does know what's going on, and I feel like she's not telling me. She knows what she's there to do. She knows about the barrier (that I guess she made?). She knows what the cloud is, or at least thinks she does.
And because I don't know, I'm not in there with her. I don't feel her fear, because I don't understand why she's afraid, or what she thinks the cloud is going to do to her. I don't know her goal or the stakes or anything.
So my suggestion is don't be afraid to explain things. You don't have to explain them in paragraph one, but by two or three, I want to know what Rhanee thinks the cloud is, what her understanding of it is. Not all of it, but enough so I can follow the rest with her.
What do the rest of you guys think?
If you'd like to submit your first impact material, send it to firstimpactAE@gmail.com. Details here.
Remember, anyone who offers their comments this month is eligible for either $10 for Amazon or B&N OR a 20-page critique from me.
This week we have the first page of a YA fantasy from KayC. My overall thoughts are at the end. As always, this is all just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
First Page
It wasn’t a white feathery cloud, the sort that
danced around in the sunlight on a spring afternoon. It was flat, and dark, and
moved with intent.
|
| This is a little too much description for me. It slows things down. I wanna know what the cloud is. |
Rhanee stood on top of a
bare knoll as the mist sank towards her. In the distance, a crimson moon
followed its smaller white counterpart over the rim of a mountain range. Behind
her the sun sank toward the horizon.
|
| What does the image of her grand- mother have to do with the creepy cloud that's trying to grab her? |
The leading edge of the cloud
reared up and wispy tentacles slithered towards her. She swallowed as an image
of her grandmother, lying in the hospital bed with staring, blank eyes, flitted
through her mind. Her legs began to tremble. It was too late to change her
mind, too late to run.
|
| What barrier? |
She clutched her arms to
her chest and scrunched her face in concentration. The air around
her shimmered and a translucent bubble appeared. Her arms dropped to her sides
as the mist crept around the glassy surface of the barrier.
|
| I really want to know what she's talking about. |
She chewed on her lip and
sighed. But I’ve got to do it now,
before I really lose my nerve. She clenched both hands until her
fingernails dug into her palm. Be brave. The
adults are too afraid, but I’m not! She clamped her teeth and
released the barrier. Sweat broke out along her forehead as the
cloud closed in and began to wrap around her. Wave after wave of despair washed
over her.
Be
brave. She sucked in a lung full of air and lifted her chin. “What
are you? Where did you come from?”
No answer.
The swirling mantle
thickened. Icy shards of grief and longing stabbed at her, burrowing like
frenzied worms. Rhanee swiped at a tear as she dropped to one
knee. I didn’t think it would be this
bad.
Adam's Thoughts
Writing? Solid. Voice? Great. I've got nothing to say about these things.
My problem here is I don't know what's going on. Normally that wouldn't be so bad, but the problem is that the narrator does know what's going on, and I feel like she's not telling me. She knows what she's there to do. She knows about the barrier (that I guess she made?). She knows what the cloud is, or at least thinks she does.
And because I don't know, I'm not in there with her. I don't feel her fear, because I don't understand why she's afraid, or what she thinks the cloud is going to do to her. I don't know her goal or the stakes or anything.
So my suggestion is don't be afraid to explain things. You don't have to explain them in paragraph one, but by two or three, I want to know what Rhanee thinks the cloud is, what her understanding of it is. Not all of it, but enough so I can follow the rest with her.
What do the rest of you guys think?
First Impact: DRUID'S MOON by Deniz Bevan
It's time for another First Impact Critique,
where we take a look at your queries, first pages, back cover copy, and more.
You want to make an impact right from the start. We're here to help
you do that.
BUT BEFORE WE GET THERE, I neglected to announce a winner for January. That winner is . . . . . . . . . K Callard! E-mail me at adamheine@gmail.com, and let me know if you'd like the gift card or the critique.
The rest of you remember, anyone who offers their comments this month is eligible for either $10 for Amazon or B&N OR a 20-page critique from me.
If you'd like to submit your first impact material, send it to firstimpactAE@gmail.com. Details here.
This week we have the first page of a paranormal romance from Deniz Bevan. My overall thoughts are at the end. As always, this is all just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
First Page
“’The Curse of the Octopus,’” Lyne read out loud, translating the runes as she went. The vellum crackled in her hands, even inside its plastic covering.
“Octopus? Are you certain of that?” Professor Ronald peered over her shoulder. His brows rose as he read, lips moving. “There seems to be a mark here,” he muttered, and tilted the sheet towards the light coming from the entrance to the cave.
The rest of the team was outside, tiny figures in the distance, kneeling on grass and mud. Lyne had been continuing her excavations near the well at the far end of the site, when she’d uncovered the crumbling parchment. She’d raced back to the cave to tell Professor Ronald and gather up the protective covering and other tools. Once the Professor was satisfied there were no other sheets, and not even so much as a lead case to hold the lone parchment, she’d followed him to the cave, eager to be there as he speculated on the meaning of the inscription.
She worked out the next two lines under his pointing finger. “Beast brought forth by man’s blood / the mound-keeper repays the sacrifice, but shall sense the wind.”
She hadn’t spoken them aloud, but a thrill went through her at the words. There was violence inherent in their tone, even if she had no idea what they meant.
Adam's Thoughts
The language geek in me is loving this.
Honestly, this whole opening sounds really good to me. The writing is solid. The mystery draws me in immediately. And the last lines she translates hint of an exciting story to come.
If I had to nitpick on something (and I do, cuz why else are you here?), I'm wondering how a single, crumbling parchment survived after having been buried for (presumably) so long. Maybe this is something unusual that you deal with later (you did call out the fact that wasn't so much as a lead case, for example), but it made me wonder.
Also, if the vellum is crackling in her hands, doesn't that mean the "crumbling" parchment is crumbling even further? It makes me wonder about their archaeological practices at this particular dig -- not that I'm an expert or anything.
What do the rest of you think?
BUT BEFORE WE GET THERE, I neglected to announce a winner for January. That winner is . . . . . . . . . K Callard! E-mail me at adamheine@gmail.com, and let me know if you'd like the gift card or the critique.
The rest of you remember, anyone who offers their comments this month is eligible for either $10 for Amazon or B&N OR a 20-page critique from me.
If you'd like to submit your first impact material, send it to firstimpactAE@gmail.com. Details here.
This week we have the first page of a paranormal romance from Deniz Bevan. My overall thoughts are at the end. As always, this is all just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
First Page
“’The Curse of the Octopus,’” Lyne read out loud, translating the runes as she went. The vellum crackled in her hands, even inside its plastic covering.
“Octopus? Are you certain of that?” Professor Ronald peered over her shoulder. His brows rose as he read, lips moving. “There seems to be a mark here,” he muttered, and tilted the sheet towards the light coming from the entrance to the cave.
The rest of the team was outside, tiny figures in the distance, kneeling on grass and mud. Lyne had been continuing her excavations near the well at the far end of the site, when she’d uncovered the crumbling parchment. She’d raced back to the cave to tell Professor Ronald and gather up the protective covering and other tools. Once the Professor was satisfied there were no other sheets, and not even so much as a lead case to hold the lone parchment, she’d followed him to the cave, eager to be there as he speculated on the meaning of the inscription.
She worked out the next two lines under his pointing finger. “Beast brought forth by man’s blood / the mound-keeper repays the sacrifice, but shall sense the wind.”
|
| If she didn't speak them aloud, maybe they should be in italics. |
Adam's Thoughts
The language geek in me is loving this.
Honestly, this whole opening sounds really good to me. The writing is solid. The mystery draws me in immediately. And the last lines she translates hint of an exciting story to come.
If I had to nitpick on something (and I do, cuz why else are you here?), I'm wondering how a single, crumbling parchment survived after having been buried for (presumably) so long. Maybe this is something unusual that you deal with later (you did call out the fact that wasn't so much as a lead case, for example), but it made me wonder.
Also, if the vellum is crackling in her hands, doesn't that mean the "crumbling" parchment is crumbling even further? It makes me wonder about their archaeological practices at this particular dig -- not that I'm an expert or anything.
What do the rest of you think?
First Impact: THE LEGACY OF THE EYE (first page) by Patricia Moussatche
It's time for another First Impact Critique,
where we take a look at your queries, first pages, back cover copy, and more.
You want to make an impact right from the start. We're here to help
you do that.
If you'd like to submit your first impact material, send it to firstimpactAE@gmail.com. Details here.
Remember, anyone who offers their comments this month is eligible for either $10 for Amazon or B&N OR a 20-page critique from me.
This week we have the first page of a sci-fi novel from Patricia Moussatche. Some of you may remember critiquing the query for this one. My overall thoughts are at the end. As always, this is all just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
UPDATE: Patricia has a revised version of the first paragraph in the comments.
First Page
Chapter 1--Proposal
Catrine blinked as her eyes adjusted to the brightness outside the school building. She should have worn a hat. She glanced at David, who had closed the heavy wood door behind them. Her best friend’s smile was as bright as the afternoon light. This was the first time either of them had left the school since their enrollment at the age of two. They were both eighteen now, but David looked ready to conquer the galaxy.
“Maybe we should go over your speech one more time,” she said.
His smile dimmed. “We went over it five times on the way here.”
“Four. And you’re still forgetting to mention that the tutors will be traveling to the pupil’s home planet. That’s the whole point of the proposal.”
“Do you want to give the speech?”
Her inside twisted in knots. “No.”
"Then stop fretting. If the council hadn’t liked our idea, they wouldn’t have requested an audience.”
“They probably read the proposal once. You’ve read it a dozen times and you still forget some of the details. I should have made you write it.”
David's smile returned. “Then it wouldn’t have been perfect.”
Or written at all, she thought.
Adam's Thoughts
I've actually read an earlier version of this (Patricia was one of the lucky winners of the 20-page critique). So keep in mind that I have more of the backstory in my head than a new reader might.
I really like the banter between them. It feels natural, shows off the characters (especially Catrine), gives useful information without being obvious about it, and it even makes me smile in a couple of places.
I'm less certain about the opening paragraph. It feels slower and less interesting to me. I don't think it should be cut necessarily, because it grounds us, but it didn't shine for me like the dialog did.
What do the rest of you guys think?
If you'd like to submit your first impact material, send it to firstimpactAE@gmail.com. Details here.
Remember, anyone who offers their comments this month is eligible for either $10 for Amazon or B&N OR a 20-page critique from me.
This week we have the first page of a sci-fi novel from Patricia Moussatche. Some of you may remember critiquing the query for this one. My overall thoughts are at the end. As always, this is all just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
UPDATE: Patricia has a revised version of the first paragraph in the comments.
First Page
Chapter 1--Proposal
Catrine blinked as her eyes adjusted to the brightness outside the school building. She should have worn a hat. She glanced at David, who had closed the heavy wood door behind them. Her best friend’s smile was as bright as the afternoon light. This was the first time either of them had left the school since their enrollment at the age of two. They were both eighteen now, but David looked ready to conquer the galaxy.
“Maybe we should go over your speech one more time,” she said.
His smile dimmed. “We went over it five times on the way here.”
“Four. And you’re still forgetting to mention that the tutors will be traveling to the pupil’s home planet. That’s the whole point of the proposal.”
“Do you want to give the speech?”
Her inside twisted in knots. “No.”
"Then stop fretting. If the council hadn’t liked our idea, they wouldn’t have requested an audience.”
“They probably read the proposal once. You’ve read it a dozen times and you still forget some of the details. I should have made you write it.”
David's smile returned. “Then it wouldn’t have been perfect.”
Or written at all, she thought.
Adam's Thoughts
I've actually read an earlier version of this (Patricia was one of the lucky winners of the 20-page critique). So keep in mind that I have more of the backstory in my head than a new reader might.
I really like the banter between them. It feels natural, shows off the characters (especially Catrine), gives useful information without being obvious about it, and it even makes me smile in a couple of places.
I'm less certain about the opening paragraph. It feels slower and less interesting to me. I don't think it should be cut necessarily, because it grounds us, but it didn't shine for me like the dialog did.
What do the rest of you guys think?
First Impact: CHRYSALIS by Melissa Grebeleski
It's time for another First Impact Critique,
where we take a look at your queries, first pages, back cover copy, etc.
You want to make an impact right from the start. We're here to help
you do that.
If you'd like to submit your first impact material, send it to firstimpactAE@gmail.com. Details here.
Remember, anyone who offers their comments this month is eligible for either $10 for Amazon or B&N OR a 20-page critique from me. I will draw a winner for January in just a few days, so get commenting.
This week we have a query for a YA fantasy. My inline comments are to the side, with overall thoughts at the end. As always, this is all just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
UPDATE (1/31, 9 AM): Melissa has posted a revised version of her query in the comments. Take a look and let her know what you think.
Query
Seventeen year-old Ivy Chapel, an archangel with amnesia, unknowingly possesses the healing power for all mankind. While trying to remember her past, Ivy must guard her heart and soul against the enemies standing in her way.
I am searching for representation for my completed 107,074-word 107,000-word young adult novel, titled Chrysalis. The book is about a girl discovering the incredible truth about her destiny. The story entwines love, loyalty, betrayal and sacrifice.
Fairy tales and folklore. T, that’s what it sounds like to Ivy. Who would ever believe that she’s an archangel with amnesia, let alone the sole guardian of God’s power to heal everything for all mankind? One person does—her parents’ new tenant, handsome and arrogant William. He tells Ivy the strangest story about an angel being hidden on Earth in the form of a baby, a child forced by her spiritual parents to remain human until the rebellion of Lucifer ended, making it safe for her to come home. But something went terribly wrong. Ivy was never returned to heaven and now that she’s all grown up she finds herself the target of every demonic being. After two attempts on her life, Ivy realizes there might be more to William’s story and that truth can be far stranger than fiction. Her new boyfriend, Lucian, is charming and sophisticated. But there’s something about him she can’t quite figure out. As she slowly regains her spiritual abilities, Ivy finds herself caught between love and loyalty. William and Lucian hold the secrets of her past and the outcome of her future. One wants her heart. One wants her soul. Will she be able to survive them both and save the world?
Chrysalis is my first novel. I’m a stay at home mother and have been writing privately for friends and family for many years.
Although Chrysalis stands alone as a novel, I have started on its sequel ideas for a sequel. I look forward to the opportunity to send you a few chapters, or the entire manuscript, of Chrysalis at your request. The finished manuscript is available on request. Please feel free to contact me using the email address. Please know that I have submitted queries to other agencies. Thank you for your time and consideration.
Adam's Thoughts
I think there's an intriguing story here (if you're not sick of angel stories, which I'm not; but I've heard agents tire of it in the past so watch out). But I think it gets lost behind what looks to me like an amateur query (sorry).
Lots of these problems are structural and easily fixed. For example:
I like the concept of a teenager who doesn't realize she's really an archangel (and it makes a lot more sense than a 17-year-old archangel :-). That's your hook. And I guess William's arrival and the attempts on her life are the inciting incident.
But then the query gets a bit vague. It brings up a character that sounds like he's always been there, but feels like he came out of nowhere. And this character has a secret, but we don't get to know what it is.
Now, you don't necessarily need to tell us the secret, but the way this is written now, not knowing the secrets makes her sadistic choice meaningless to us. She has to choose between "love and loyalty," but who's love? And loyalty to whom? "One wants her heart. One wants her soul." But which is which? And why?
This is where you need to get specific. If we don't understand the protagonist's choice, then we can't care, no matter how much we want to. What makes a choice really sadistic is when the reader understands what goes into the choice, and they still have no idea what they would choose if it were them.
That's my opinion, anyway. What do the rest of you guys think?
If you'd like to submit your first impact material, send it to firstimpactAE@gmail.com. Details here.
Remember, anyone who offers their comments this month is eligible for either $10 for Amazon or B&N OR a 20-page critique from me. I will draw a winner for January in just a few days, so get commenting.
This week we have a query for a YA fantasy. My inline comments are to the side, with overall thoughts at the end. As always, this is all just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
UPDATE (1/31, 9 AM): Melissa has posted a revised version of her query in the comments. Take a look and let her know what you think.
Query
|
| How can an archangel be seventeen? |
|
| I'd move this to the top or the bottom of the query. |
|
| Long paragraph. Maybe split it up. At first I thought this meant that archangels have parents. If she wasn't returned, does that Lucifer's rebellion is over? Lucian feels like he comes out of the blue to me. And his secrets are too vague for me to follow. |
Chrysalis is my first novel. I’m a stay at home mother and have been writing privately for friends and family for many years.
|
| It's up to you whether you want to write a sequel for a story that hasn't sold, but as far as the query goes, just say it has series potential. |
Adam's Thoughts
I think there's an intriguing story here (if you're not sick of angel stories, which I'm not; but I've heard agents tire of it in the past so watch out). But I think it gets lost behind what looks to me like an amateur query (sorry).
Lots of these problems are structural and easily fixed. For example:
- The logline paragraph that repeats information stated later in the query. I've talked about this before.
- Citing word count down to the exact word (generally round to the neareast thousand).
- Telling what the story's about instead of letting the query show it (e.g. "[It's] about a girl discovering the incredible truth," etc).
- Big Block of Text.
- Superfluous information in the conclusion paragraph (mostly stuff that agents assume is true).
I like the concept of a teenager who doesn't realize she's really an archangel (and it makes a lot more sense than a 17-year-old archangel :-). That's your hook. And I guess William's arrival and the attempts on her life are the inciting incident.
But then the query gets a bit vague. It brings up a character that sounds like he's always been there, but feels like he came out of nowhere. And this character has a secret, but we don't get to know what it is.
Now, you don't necessarily need to tell us the secret, but the way this is written now, not knowing the secrets makes her sadistic choice meaningless to us. She has to choose between "love and loyalty," but who's love? And loyalty to whom? "One wants her heart. One wants her soul." But which is which? And why?
This is where you need to get specific. If we don't understand the protagonist's choice, then we can't care, no matter how much we want to. What makes a choice really sadistic is when the reader understands what goes into the choice, and they still have no idea what they would choose if it were them.
That's my opinion, anyway. What do the rest of you guys think?
First Impact: RACHEL ON FIRE by Vanessa Shields
It's time for another First Impact Critique,
where we take a look at your queries, first pages, back cover copy, etc.
You want to make an impact right from the start. We're here to help
you do that.
If you'd like to submit your first impact material, send it to firstimpactAE@gmail.com. Details here.
Remember, anyone who offers their comments this month is eligible for either $10 for Amazon or B&N OR a 20-page critique from me.
This week we have a logline and first page for a YA Contemporary from Vanessa Shields. My inline comments are to the side, with overall thoughts at the end. As always, this is all just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
Logline
On the bus out
of town, it takes one kiss with Tom to ignite sixteen-year-old Rachel’s love.
She’s ready to uncover the truth about Tom, the blue-eyed loner, who is rumored
to have killed his parents in a house fire. Through a series of fiery firsts
that uncover Tom’s scarred story, Rachel falls courageously in love. True love
is real.
I
watched my older brother Alex fidgeting with his university acceptance letter. He
was speechless, for once. In fact, we all found ourselves happily silenced. My
parents took a sip of their coffees. Then my mom put her hand on my dad’s
shoulder. Suddenly, I felt so far out of the loop I couldn’t even see it.
Adam's Thoughts
I'm intrigued by the mystery, but I feel a little disconnected from the character. Nothing stands out to me as "wrong," but I think it's a combination of little things:
What do the rest of you guys think?
If you'd like to submit your first impact material, send it to firstimpactAE@gmail.com. Details here.
Remember, anyone who offers their comments this month is eligible for either $10 for Amazon or B&N OR a 20-page critique from me.
This week we have a logline and first page for a YA Contemporary from Vanessa Shields. My inline comments are to the side, with overall thoughts at the end. As always, this is all just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
Logline
|
| The bit about him killing his parents hooked me. I wonder if that couldn't come sooner. I'm less sure about the last line. |
First Page
|
| I was following this until the last line. Then I felt out of the loop. Why does she feel like something's up? |
“That’s
great. Really great,” my dad said. He looked at my mom. We all looked at my
mom. “Actually, we’ve got some news for you guys, too.”
A
bad feeling in my guts stood at attention.
“We’re
selling the house,” my mom said. A little sob slipped out of her mouth, which
she quickly covered with her hand.
“What?!”
I barely had enough breath to say the word.
“We
don’t need to live in this big, old thing with Alex going off to school,” my
mom said.
“Hey,
Rachel, it’ll be okay,” Alex jumped in.
“Will
it?” I glared at my mom. I couldn’t believe what my ears were hearing.
“Did
you know about this?” I looked at Alex. His eyes found my mom’s, and then he
nodded. Guilt shaded my family’s faces a bright hue of red. I pointed at them
dramatically.
“You
all knew about this! How could you not tell me?” I was shouting. I wanted to
run out of the room, but my legs were concrete heavy.
“We
should have told you Rachel,” my dad said.
I still felt like there was part of
the loop that wasn’t being revealed.
Adam's Thoughts
I'm intrigued by the mystery, but I feel a little disconnected from the character. Nothing stands out to me as "wrong," but I think it's a combination of little things:
- The sentence in the first paragraph where she feels out of the loop, but I don't even know what signals she picked up on that made her feel that way. I'm still trying to get grounded in these characters and the acceptance letter and what that means.
- I think there's something lacking in her reaction to the news. Plenty of emotions are shown, but why is this so bad for her? What does this house mean for her? (Part of this might just be me: I don't personally identify with the issue because I've never felt that way about a house.)
- It also might be that nobody else seems to have any emotions (with the exception of when her mom covers her sob -- that part's great).
- Like the first "loop" sentence, I'm not sure what signals she's picking up on to make her think they're hiding more from her.
What do the rest of you guys think?
First Impact: LOST AND FOUND AT THE BEAR CLAW BREWHOUSE
It's time for another First Impact Critique,
where we take a look at your queries, first pages, back cover copy, etc.
You want to make an impact right from the start. We're here to help
you do that.
If you'd like to submit your first impact material, send it to firstimpactAE@gmail.com. Details here.
Remember, anyone who offers their comments this month is eligible for either $10 for Amazon or B&N OR a 20-page critique from me.
This week we have the first page of a black comedy. My inline comments are to the side, with overall thoughts at the end. As always, this is all just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
First Page
I sat down on my creaky twin bed, standard issue in the 50s motel now home to Bear Claw Brewhouse employees, and lit up the joint my roommate rolled for me. If I was going to fail, I was going to fail all the way.
Adam's Thoughts
There's a lot of good stuff here. There's some nice voice and a so-far-compelling character. I like how you intertwined her grandfather's words with his actions in the flashback. This feels like a good start to me.
Be careful you don't over-explain why you're doing things. You don't need to explain that her memory is blurred and in snippets in order to introduce that particular flashback. Most of the time, you can just jump into it. Keep things tight and snappy.
And I know the adrenaline thing is really nitpicky, but that's the kind of thing that can either gain or lose the reader's trust. You have to have the reader's trust, and it starts with the small details. You don't have to research every little thing (I mean, I do, but I'm slow and obsessive), but do get good critique partners who can catch this kind of thing. It's one thing we nerds are good at :-)
How do the rest of you feel about this opening?
If you'd like to submit your first impact material, send it to firstimpactAE@gmail.com. Details here.
Remember, anyone who offers their comments this month is eligible for either $10 for Amazon or B&N OR a 20-page critique from me.
This week we have the first page of a black comedy. My inline comments are to the side, with overall thoughts at the end. As always, this is all just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
First Page
As I stared at the two little blue lines, my grandpa’s words from a few months before echoed in my head. Doped up and pregnant.
|
| I think adrenaline is produced in the brain. And it actually enhances your memory. |
The memory is a blur thanks to the massive dose of adrenaline my heart shot out when I asked to live with him while working at his competitor’s restaurant. I only remember snippets of conversation and images, like the half deer carcass over his shoulder.
No granddaughter of mine.
The cleaver, gleaming in the afternoon sun as he lifted it above his head.
Forty years I’ve run this resort. I know what goes on.
His grey eyes boring into me from over his half moon glasses.
You’ll end up doped up and pregnant, just like all those other poor innocent small town girls.
The cleaver again, this time coming down between ribs with a heavy thunk.
Looking at those blue lines,
I could feel adrenaline clouding my thoughts again. Two lines, I thought. Two beings, one body. Me and my baby. My fetus. My... embryo? Whatever. Two. One too many to prove my grandfather wrong.
|
| I'm having trouble parsing this clause. I like the end line. |
Adam's Thoughts
There's a lot of good stuff here. There's some nice voice and a so-far-compelling character. I like how you intertwined her grandfather's words with his actions in the flashback. This feels like a good start to me.
Be careful you don't over-explain why you're doing things. You don't need to explain that her memory is blurred and in snippets in order to introduce that particular flashback. Most of the time, you can just jump into it. Keep things tight and snappy.
And I know the adrenaline thing is really nitpicky, but that's the kind of thing that can either gain or lose the reader's trust. You have to have the reader's trust, and it starts with the small details. You don't have to research every little thing (I mean, I do, but I'm slow and obsessive), but do get good critique partners who can catch this kind of thing. It's one thing we nerds are good at :-)
How do the rest of you feel about this opening?
First Impact: HUNTED by Jessica Hutchison
It's time for another First Impact Critique,
where we take a look at your queries, first pages, back cover copy, etc.
You want to make an impact right from the start. We're here to help
you do that.
If you'd like to submit your first impact material, send it to firstimpactAE@gmail.com. Details here.
Remember, anyone who offers their comments this month is eligible for either $10 for Amazon or B&N OR a 20-page critique from me.
This week we have a query letter for a YA urban fantasy. My inline comments are to the side, with overall thoughts at the end. As always, this is all just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
Query
Zuza always thought superheroes were cool until she became one.
Now when her evil step-mother asks her to pass the salt, she can launch it at her head without lifting a finger. And then there's the healing. H: her regeneration power rivals a salamander's. It's that awesome.
But not everything's that coolit's not as cool as it sounds. She seriously has to worry about bounty hunters from other dimensions tracking her down and tossing her through a portal to the Phantom Zone.
It's just one more complication in an already complicated life. She's got a weird Latvian name (thanks Dad) and a pregnant step-mother determined to replace Zuza with her own spawn. That would be more than enough to handle, but now there's Raven, the intense guy with lethal eyes and a habit of punching people who try to kiss her. Somehow he's the only one who gets that she's in trouble. That she needs help. Problem is, she's having trouble deciding whose side he's on. And when she learns her superpowers are about as stable as a Russian nuclear power plant, she knows she's almost out of time.
FINDING ZUZA is an urban fantasy for young adults complete at 96,000 words. It takes a curly-headed, dramatic Felicity-like character and puts her into the fast-paced action and romantic suspense of a Cassandra Clare novel. I've published a few short stories, one titled Lazarus in the short story anthology Bicycle Love (Breakaway Books, 2004). Currently, I teach agriculture-related courses at a small university where driving tractors, shearing sheep and tapping maples are all on the syllabus.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Sincerely,
Jessica Hutchison
[address, email, blog address]
Adam's Thoughts
There is a lot of Great here. The voice and the story sound solid enough that you could probably get requests with this as is. But I bet we can make it better.
For me, the threads start to fray in the last plot paragraph ("It's just one more complication..."). Up to that point, I'm totally hooked by the character and conflict, and all I need is to know the stakes -- what she has to do and why it matters. But instead I get dumped back into family matters (which, to be honest, sound a little whiny to me considering she's got telekinesis and healing factor).
Introduce Raven for sure, but be more clear about the trouble Zuza's in. The bounty hunter paragraph makes it sound like it's an ongoing problem, rather than something new and deadly that she needs help with.
Where I really got interested again was how her powers were unstable. That's a great hook and I want to know more about it. What does she need to do before her time runs out? That's what I'm unclear on: her goal.
Those are my thoughts. What do the rest of you guys think?
If you'd like to submit your first impact material, send it to firstimpactAE@gmail.com. Details here.
Remember, anyone who offers their comments this month is eligible for either $10 for Amazon or B&N OR a 20-page critique from me.
This week we have a query letter for a YA urban fantasy. My inline comments are to the side, with overall thoughts at the end. As always, this is all just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
Query
|
| A one-sentence logline? I'm wary :-) |
|
| Oh! You went right on with the plot instead of backing up. Great! A lot of great voice here. |
|
| Just some suggestions here. Reword them to taste and, you know, accuracy. |
|
| The family issues here feel like first world problems to me. Focus on the story. |
|
| The query shows Zuza's character. You don't need to tell it. This highlighted bit is exactly how to write about yourself (if you're going to do that). |
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Sincerely,
Jessica Hutchison
[address, email, blog address]
Adam's Thoughts
There is a lot of Great here. The voice and the story sound solid enough that you could probably get requests with this as is. But I bet we can make it better.
For me, the threads start to fray in the last plot paragraph ("It's just one more complication..."). Up to that point, I'm totally hooked by the character and conflict, and all I need is to know the stakes -- what she has to do and why it matters. But instead I get dumped back into family matters (which, to be honest, sound a little whiny to me considering she's got telekinesis and healing factor).
Introduce Raven for sure, but be more clear about the trouble Zuza's in. The bounty hunter paragraph makes it sound like it's an ongoing problem, rather than something new and deadly that she needs help with.
Where I really got interested again was how her powers were unstable. That's a great hook and I want to know more about it. What does she need to do before her time runs out? That's what I'm unclear on: her goal.
Those are my thoughts. What do the rest of you guys think?
First Impact: WARRIORS OVER DARKNESS AND THE UNSETTLED GRAVE by Clarissa
I hope you all had a good vacation. Because it's time for another First Impact Critique,
where we take a look at your queries, first pages, back cover copy, etc.
You want to make an impact right from the start. We're here to help
you do that.
If you'd like to submit your first impact material, send it to firstimpactAE@gmail.com. Details here.
Remember, anyone who offers their comments this month is eligible for either $10 for Amazon or B&N OR a 20-page critique from me.
This week we have the first page of a YA urban fantasy from Clarissa. My inline comments are to the side, with overall thoughts at the end. As always, this is all just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
First Page
It was past the pier’s midnight closing hour, but
teenage lagers in their drunken stumbles were taking forever to leave
the grounds. She could hear their hoots and slurred tongues along with
the wasted giggles and sloppy kisses of insecure girls. They didn’t see
Aleera of course; but the eeriness her mere presence exuded could put
more pep in their steps than any vicious canine. She supposed it was
wrong, but even after decades of looking like a youngster fresh out of
school, abusing her abilities was a habit no rehab could ever break.
And abuse them she did. Her exhale was the prickly
sensations bouncing across their necks. Her intense gray stare burning
cracks in their backs was the feeling of a predator on prey. The dark
whispers melting from her lips were the voices inside their heads. Like
the devilish ones that tell long-face men to kill, kill, kill their
loved ones in disgusting ways…but Aleera vowed to never go that far.
If you'd like to submit your first impact material, send it to firstimpactAE@gmail.com. Details here.
Remember, anyone who offers their comments this month is eligible for either $10 for Amazon or B&N OR a 20-page critique from me.
This week we have the first page of a YA urban fantasy from Clarissa. My inline comments are to the side, with overall thoughts at the end. As always, this is all just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
First Page
|
| The highlighted bit is a little vague for me, but okay. I'm curious who thinks bloodshed is a good thing. 2nd sentence is a bit awkward. |
After-hours at the lakefront carnival was a perfect place for
bloodshed, especially the kind saddled with revenge. As an assassin of
daemonic creatures, Aleera Merrick knew that fun fact all too well
considering the shoreline was where she found plenty of her victims and
even dumped them in the very handy Lake Michigan. Plus, the high rides
and skyscrapers were great stakeout points.
|
| Isn't a lager a kind of beer? The longish, awkward sentences are starting to get to me. |
|
| I like these two highlighted lines. |
And just like that they were gone.
If
she wasn’t careful she could drive folks mad. The extent of her power
tugged slyness at her lips. Mundane humans never changed. They would
always be so easy to manipulate. It was in their nature; Adam and Eve
were proof enough. That’s precisely why she had to protect them from
creatures like to her…the untamed ones.
Adam's Thoughts
I don't think I really got into this until the third paragraph. And I think the reason is that there's a lot of thinking and telling here, but the third paragraph is where we really get to see what Aleera can do. And it's awesome and it's creepy.
Not that you can't ever tell. Sometimes that's just what you gotta do. But it'll draw the reader in more if she's doing something, and if we can learn about her through what she does.
I think this is why people say you should start with action. Not because you need exciting openings with explosions, but because we want to do something with the character, rather than read her thoughts.
And it does seem like a fascinating world. Aleera is an intriguing anti-hero, and I'm curious what shakes up her world.
So, what do the rest of you guys think?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)